top of page

Liberalism discussed at Adult Formation

Blessed John Cardinal Henry Newman once wrote in his work Apologia Pro Vita Sua (A Defence of One's Own Life) that he had always resisted "Liberalism" in religion. In order to answer the question, "What is meant by 'Liberalism?'" he begins by calling it the "anti-dogmatic spirit" but says this is an insufficient description. He gives a list of propositions that put a finger on the Dogmas of Liberalism.

It's important to note here that "Liberalism" is not a way in which Blessed Newman is picking on this or that modern political party, but it is important to note that all American political parties are Developments (to use Newman's concept) or Corruptions of The Liberal Tradition. I.E. conservatives and liberals are LIberals arguing about developments of the first principles they both agree on.

Blessed Newman seems to think in no way, shape, form, or fashion can any of The Liberal Tradition's tenants be wed to The Catholic Tradition. Talk about being in but not of The World. We'll finish this phase of Adult Formation & Mystagogy by looking at The Church's formal condemnation of Liberalism in all its iterations as heresy and think about what it means to not be self-deceived, how to practice The Faith in a Liberal Protestant nation, and how to evangelize given these are the waters we swim in.

St. Aelred will cover these propositions throughout May and June. Our current Sunday Schedule is:

Mass: 8 AM

Adult Formation & Mystagogy: 9:30 - 10:30 AM

Please keep an eye on the web site for changes. As Deacon Gregory's ordination approaches (June 29th) we will prepare to move to a 10 AM Mass time with Adult Formation & Mystagogy to follow that Mass time.

Feel free to print these and bring them with you. For the sake of growing in holiness, try using the 18 propositions as a quiz. Do I believe in any of these in thought, word, or in deed? Why is the Catholic Church against such propositions? What would Christ have me do about this?


Eighteen Dogmas of Liberalism

1. No religious tenet is important, unless reason shows it to be so.

Therefore, e.g. the doctrine of the Athanasian Creed is not to be insisted on, unless it tends to convert the soul; and the doctrine of the Atonement is to be insisted on, if it does convert the soul.

2. No one can believe what he does not understand.

Therefore, e.g. there are no mysteries in true religion.

3. No theological doctrine is any thing more than an opinion which happens to be held by bodies of men.

Therefore, e.g. no creed, as such, is necessary for salvation.

4. It is dishonest in a man to make an act of faith in what he has not had brought home to him by actual proof.

Therefore, e.g. the mass of men ought not absolutely to believe in the divine authority of the Bible.

5. It is immoral in a man to believe more than he can spontaneously receive as being congenial to his moral and mental nature.

Therefore, e.g. a given individual is not bound to believe in eternal punishment.

6. No revealed doctrines or precepts may reasonably stand in the way of scientific conclusions.

Therefore, e.g. Political Economy may reverse our Lord's declarations about poverty and riches, or a system of Ethics may teach that the highest condition of body is ordinarily essential to the highest state of mind.

7. Christianity is necessarily modified by the growth of civilization, and the exigencies of times.

Therefore, e.g. the Catholic priesthood, though necessary in the Middle Ages, may be superseded now.

8. There is a system of religion more simply true than Christianity as it has ever been received.

Therefore, e.g. we may advance that Christianity is the "corn of wheat " which has been dead for 1800 years, but at length will bear fruit; and that Mahometanism is the manly religion, and existing Christianity the womanish. {500}

9. There is a right of Private Judgment: that is, there is no existing authority on earth competent to interfere with the liberty of individuals in reasoning and judging for themselves about the Bible and its contents, as they severally please.

Therefore, e.g. religious establishments requiring subscription are Anti-christian.

10. There are rights of conscience such, that every one may lawfully advance a claim to profess and teach what is false and wrong in matters, religious, social, and moral, provided that to his private conscience it seems absolutely true and right.

Therefore, e.g. individuals have a right to preach and practise fornication and polygamy.

11. There is no such thing as a national or state conscience.

Therefore, e.g. no judgments can fall upon a sinful or infidel nation.

12. The civil power has no positive duty, in a normal state of things, to maintain religious truth.

Therefore, e.g. blasphemy and sabbath-breaking are not rightly punishable by law.

13. Utility and expedience are the measure of political duty.

Therefore, e.g. no punishment may be enacted, on the ground that God commands it: e.g. on the text, "Whoso sheddeth man's blood, by man shall his blood be shed."

14. The Civil Power may dispose of Church property without sacrilege.

Therefore, e.g. Henry VIII. committed no sin in his spoliations.

15. The Civil Power has the right of ecclesiastical jurisdiction and administration.

Therefore, e.g. Parliament may impose articles of faith on the Church or suppress Dioceses. {501}

16. It is lawful to rise in arms against legitimate princes.

Therefore, e.g. the Puritans in the 17th century, and the French in the 18th, were justifiable in their Rebellion and Revolution respectively.

17. The people are the legitimate source of power.

Therefore, e.g. Universal Suffrage is among the natural rights of man.

18. Virtue is the child of knowledge, and vice of ignorance.

Therefore, e.g. education, periodical literature, railroad travelling, ventilation, drainage, and the arts of life, when fully carried out, serve to make a population moral and happy.

bottom of page